In‐text author citation analysis: Feasibility, benefits, and limitations
Dangzhi Zhao, Andreas Strotmann
Abstract
Dangzhi Zhao, Andreas Strotmann
Abstract
This article explores the feasibility, benefits, and limitations of in‐text author citation analysis and tests how well it works compared with traditional author citation analysis using citation databases. In‐text author citation analysis refers to author‐based citation analysis using in‐text citation data from full‐text articles rather than reference data from citation databases. It has the potential to help with the application of citation analysis to research fields such as the social sciences that are not covered well by citation databases and to support weighted citation and cocitation counting for improved citation analysis results. We found that in‐text author citation analysis can work as well as traditional citation analysis using citation databases for both author ranking and mapping if author name disambiguation is performed properly. Using in‐text citation data without any author name disambiguation, ranking authors by citations is useless, whereas cocitation analysis works well for identifying major specialties and their interrelationships with cautions required for the interpretation of small research areas and some authors' memberships in specialties.
OpenAlex reports 16 citations for this work. Citation counts describe recorded attention and do not establish research quality.
A contribution statement is not available in the OpenAlex record.
Method details are not available in the OpenAlex metadata.
Findings are not separately available in the OpenAlex metadata.
Limitations are not available in the OpenAlex metadata.
Application details are not available in the OpenAlex metadata.
This article explores the feasibility, benefits, and limitations of in‐text author citation analysis and tests how well it works compared with traditional author citation analysis using citation databases. In‐text author citation analysis refers to author‐based citation analysis using in‐text citation data from full‐text articles rather than reference data from citation databases. It has the potential to help with the application of citation analysis to research fields such as the social sciences that are not covered well by citation databases and to support weighted citation and cocitation counting for improved citation analysis results. We found that in‐text author citation analysis can work as well as traditional citation analysis using citation databases for both author ranking and mapping if author name disambiguation is performed properly. Using in‐text citation data without any author name disambiguation, ranking authors by citations is useless, whereas cocitation analysis works well for identifying major specialties and their interrelationships with cautions required for the interpretation of small research areas and some authors' memberships in specialties.
Key concepts: Citation, Ranking (information retrieval), Computer science, Citation analysis, Information retrieval, Data science, World Wide Web