2015BMJRequires access

Middle East respiratory syndrome coronavirus (MERS-CoV) in pilgrims returning from the Hajj

Alexander Kumar, Gail Beckett, Martin Wiselka

Open publisher page 10 citations

Abstract

Background: The hypothesis that initiation of DMARD-treatment before arthritis becomes apparent could permanently modulate the disease process, such that persistent RA is prevented, is being studied in several ongoing trials. Essential for such studies is the ability to accurately predict clinically apparent inflammatory arthritis (IA). However there are two hurdles: first, it is insufficiently known whether it is possible to obtain high positive predictive values (PPV) in patients presenting with clinically suspect arthralgia (CSA). Second, none of current predictive models is validated in independent cohorts. We here aimed to evaluate the first question, incorporating improved markers of MRI-detected subclinical inflammation that were recently identified but have not yet been combined with other known predictors.[1] Objectives: To assess the feasibility of achieving high PPVs in prediction of IA-development in patients with CSA by combining clinical, laboratory and imaging parameters. Methods: 580 patients with CSA were consecutively included in the Clinically Suspect Arthralgia (CSA)-cohort and followed on the development of IA, determined by physical examination of joints. Unilateral contrast-enhanced 1.5 Tesla MRIs were made of MCP(2-5), wrist and MTP(1-5)-joints at baseline and scored in line with the RAMRIS. The number of locations with subclinical inflammation (0/1-2/≥3) and the presence of MCP peritendinitis were defined as described previously.[1] Other studied clinical and laboratory variables were based on the literature: initial localisation of complaints (small/large joints), functional disability (health assessment questionnaire (HAQ) ≥1), ACPA-positivity (Anti-CCP2), RF-positivity (IgM-RF) and elevated CRP.[2,3] LASSO Cox regression with a 10-fold cross-validated shrinkage parameter was used for predictor selection. Regression coefficients were rounded to the nearest number ending in .5 or .0 and multiplied by two, resulting in a weighted score. Kaplan Meijer curves were used to obtain PPVs of this weighted score and the area under the curve (AUC) was determined at 2-year follow-up. Results: Mean age was 44, 78% was female, and 18% progressed to IA within 2 years. The following parameters were selected with LASSO: RF-positivity, ACPA-positivity, HAQ≥1, >2 locations of subclinical inflammation and presence of MCP-extensor peritendinitis. Based on the beta of LASSO-regression, patients were assigned 2 points for the risk-factors ACPA-positivity and >2 locations of subclinical inflammation, 1 point for RF-positivity and presence of MCP-extensor peritendinitis and 0 points for HAQ≥1. Kaplan Meijer curves show PPVs of 8%, 9%, 30%, 54%, 73%, 79% and 86% at two years (Figure 1). This model yielded an AUC of 0.79. Conclusion: High PPVs for IA-development can be achieved in patients with CSA by weighting a combination of known predictors. Although encouraging, these data are based on one observational cohort study and have not been validated in independent cohorts, limiting the relevance. To support future research in the field of arthralgia, it is needed that different research groups work together to come to risk estimations that are validated and accepted. References: [1] Matthijssen XME et al. ART 2019;21(1):249-. [2] van Steenbergen HW et al. ART 2014;16(2):R92. [3] ten Brinck RM et al. RMD Open 2017;3(1):e000419. Disclosure of Interests: None declared

About this research paper

What this paper is about

Background: The hypothesis that initiation of DMARD-treatment before arthritis becomes apparent could permanently modulate the disease process, such that persistent RA is prevented, is being studied in several ongoing trials. Essential for such studies is the ability to accurately predict clinically apparent inflammatory arthritis (IA). However there are two hurdles: first, it is insufficiently known whether it is possible to obtain high positive predictive values (PPV) in patients presenting with clinically suspect arthralgia (CSA). Second, none of current predictive models is validated in independent cohorts. We here aimed to evaluate the first question, incorporating improved markers of MRI-detected subclinical inflammation that were recently identified but have not yet been combined with other known predictors.[1] Objectives: To assess the feasibility of achieving high PPVs in prediction of IA-development in patients with CSA by combining clinical, laboratory and imaging parameters. Methods: 580 patients with CSA were consecutively included in the Clinically Suspect Arthralgia (CSA)-cohort and followed on the development of IA, determined by physical examination of joints. Unilateral contrast-enhanced 1.5 Tesla MRIs were made of MCP(2-5), wrist and MTP(1-5)-joints at baseline and scored in line with the RAMRIS. The number of locations with subclinical inflammation (0/1-2/≥3) and the presence of MCP peritendinitis were defined as described previously.[1] Other studied clinical and laboratory variables were based on the literature: initial localisation of complaints (small/large joints), functional disability (health assessment questionnaire (HAQ) ≥1), ACPA-positivity (Anti-CCP2), RF-positivity (IgM-RF) and elevated CRP.[2,3] LASSO Cox regression with a 10-fold cross-validated shrinkage parameter was used for predictor selection. Regression coefficients were rounded to the nearest number ending in .5 or .0 and multiplied by two, resulting in a weighted score. Kaplan Meijer curves were used to obtain PPVs of this weighted score and the area under the curve (AUC) was determined at 2-year follow-up. Results: Mean age was 44, 78% was female, and 18% progressed to IA within 2 years. The following parameters were selected with LASSO: RF-positivity, ACPA-positivity, HAQ≥1, >2 locations of subclinical inflammation and presence of MCP-extensor peritendinitis. Based on the beta of LASSO-regression, patients were assigned 2 points for the risk-factors ACPA-positivity and >2 locations of subclinical inflammation, 1 point for RF-positivity and presence of MCP-extensor peritendinitis and 0 points for HAQ≥1. Kaplan Meijer curves show PPVs of 8%, 9%, 30%, 54%, 73%, 79% and 86% at two years (Figure 1). This model yielded an AUC of 0.79. Conclusion: High PPVs for IA-development can be achieved in patients with CSA by weighting a combination of known predictors. Although encouraging, these data are based on one observational cohort study and have not been validated in independent cohorts, limiting the relevance. To support future research in the field of arthralgia, it is needed that different research groups work together to come to risk estimations that are validated and accepted. References: [1] Matthijssen XME et al. ART 2019;21(1):249-. [2] van Steenbergen HW et al. ART 2014;16(2):R92. [3] ten Brinck RM et al. RMD Open 2017;3(1):e000419. Disclosure of Interests: None declared

Why it matters

OpenAlex reports 10 citations for this work. Citation counts describe recorded attention and do not establish research quality.

Key contribution

A contribution statement is not available in the OpenAlex record.

Method / approach

Method details are not available in the OpenAlex metadata.

Main findings

Findings are not separately available in the OpenAlex metadata.

Limitations

Limitations are not available in the OpenAlex metadata.

Applications

Application details are not available in the OpenAlex metadata.

Available abstract

Background: The hypothesis that initiation of DMARD-treatment before arthritis becomes apparent could permanently modulate the disease process, such that persistent RA is prevented, is being studied in several ongoing trials. Essential for such studies is the ability to accurately predict clinically apparent inflammatory arthritis (IA). However there are two hurdles: first, it is insufficiently known whether it is possible to obtain high positive predictive values (PPV) in patients presenting with clinically suspect arthralgia (CSA). Second, none of current predictive models is validated in independent cohorts. We here aimed to evaluate the first question, incorporating improved markers of MRI-detected subclinical inflammation that were recently identified but have not yet been combined with other known predictors.[1] Objectives: To assess the feasibility of achieving high PPVs in prediction of IA-development in patients with CSA by combining clinical, laboratory and imaging parameters. Methods: 580 patients with CSA were consecutively included in the Clinically Suspect Arthralgia (CSA)-cohort and followed on the development of IA, determined by physical examination of joints. Unilateral contrast-enhanced 1.5 Tesla MRIs were made of MCP(2-5), wrist and MTP(1-5)-joints at baseline and scored in line with the RAMRIS. The number of locations with subclinical inflammation (0/1-2/≥3) and the presence of MCP peritendinitis were defined as described previously.[1] Other studied clinical and laboratory variables were based on the literature: initial localisation of complaints (small/large joints), functional disability (health assessment questionnaire (HAQ) ≥1), ACPA-positivity (Anti-CCP2), RF-positivity (IgM-RF) and elevated CRP.[2,3] LASSO Cox regression with a 10-fold cross-validated shrinkage parameter was used for predictor selection. Regression coefficients were rounded to the nearest number ending in .5 or .0 and multiplied by two, resulting in a weighted score. Kaplan Meijer curves were used to obtain PPVs of this weighted score and the area under the curve (AUC) was determined at 2-year follow-up. Results: Mean age was 44, 78% was female, and 18% progressed to IA within 2 years. The following parameters were selected with LASSO: RF-positivity, ACPA-positivity, HAQ≥1, >2 locations of subclinical inflammation and presence of MCP-extensor peritendinitis. Based on the beta of LASSO-regression, patients were assigned 2 points for the risk-factors ACPA-positivity and >2 locations of subclinical inflammation, 1 point for RF-positivity and presence of MCP-extensor peritendinitis and 0 points for HAQ≥1. Kaplan Meijer curves show PPVs of 8%, 9%, 30%, 54%, 73%, 79% and 86% at two years (Figure 1). This model yielded an AUC of 0.79. Conclusion: High PPVs for IA-development can be achieved in patients with CSA by weighting a combination of known predictors. Although encouraging, these data are based on one observational cohort study and have not been validated in independent cohorts, limiting the relevance. To support future research in the field of arthralgia, it is needed that different research groups work together to come to risk estimations that are validated and accepted. References: [1] Matthijssen XME et al. ART 2019;21(1):249-. [2] van Steenbergen HW et al. ART 2014;16(2):R92. [3] ten Brinck RM et al. RMD Open 2017;3(1):e000419. Disclosure of Interests: None declared

Key concepts: Medicine, Subclinical infection, Internal medicine, Cohort, Arthritis, Rheumatoid arthritis, Physical therapy

Related papers

Back to paper searchBrowse research topicsOriginal source
Middle East respiratory syndrome coronavirus (MERS-CoV) in pilgrims returning from the Hajj — Research Paper | ScholarLens