2002arXiv (Cornell University)Open access

Using Balmer line profiles to investigate convection in A and F stars

B. Smalley, F. Kupka

Open full text 0 citations

Abstract

Balmer lines are an important diagnostic of stellar atmospheric structure, since they are formed at a wide range of depths within the atmosphere. The different Balmer lines are formed at slightly different depths making them useful atmospheric diagnostics. The low sensitivity to surface gravity for stars cooler than ~8000 K makes them excellent diagnostics in the treatment of atmospheric convection. For hotter stars Balmer profiles are sensitive to both effective temperature and surface gravity. Provided we know the surface gravity of these stars from some other method (e.g. from eclipsing binary systems), we can use them to determine effective temperature. In previous work, we have found no significant systematic problems with using uvby photometry to determine atmospheric parameters of fundamental (and standard) stars. In fact, uvby was found to be very good for obtaining both Teff and log g. Using Halpha and Hbeta profiles, we have found that both the Canuto & Mazzitteli and standard Kurucz mixing-length theory without approximate overshooting are both in agreement to within the uncertainties of the fundamental stars. Overshooting models were always clearly discrepant. Some evidence was found for significant disagreement between all treatments of convection and fundamental values around 8000~9000K, but these results were for fundamental stars without fundamental surface gravities. We have used stars with fundamental values of both Teff and log g to explore this region in more detail.

Open-access reader

About this research paper

What this paper is about

Balmer lines are an important diagnostic of stellar atmospheric structure, since they are formed at a wide range of depths within the atmosphere. The different Balmer lines are formed at slightly different depths making them useful atmospheric diagnostics. The low sensitivity to surface gravity for stars cooler than ~8000 K makes them excellent diagnostics in the treatment of atmospheric convection. For hotter stars Balmer profiles are sensitive to both effective temperature and surface gravity. Provided we know the surface gravity of these stars from some other method (e.g. from eclipsing binary systems), we can use them to determine effective temperature. In previous work, we have found no significant systematic problems with using uvby photometry to determine atmospheric parameters of fundamental (and standard) stars. In fact, uvby was found to be very good for obtaining both Teff and log g. Using Halpha and Hbeta profiles, we have found that both the Canuto & Mazzitteli and standard Kurucz mixing-length theory without approximate overshooting are both in agreement to within the uncertainties of the fundamental stars. Overshooting models were always clearly discrepant. Some evidence was found for significant disagreement between all treatments of convection and fundamental values around 8000~9000K, but these results were for fundamental stars without fundamental surface gravities. We have used stars with fundamental values of both Teff and log g to explore this region in more detail.

Why it matters

A significance statement is not available in the OpenAlex record.

Key contribution

A contribution statement is not available in the OpenAlex record.

Method / approach

Method details are not available in the OpenAlex metadata.

Main findings

Findings are not separately available in the OpenAlex metadata.

Limitations

Limitations are not available in the OpenAlex metadata.

Applications

Application details are not available in the OpenAlex metadata.

Available abstract

Balmer lines are an important diagnostic of stellar atmospheric structure, since they are formed at a wide range of depths within the atmosphere. The different Balmer lines are formed at slightly different depths making them useful atmospheric diagnostics. The low sensitivity to surface gravity for stars cooler than ~8000 K makes them excellent diagnostics in the treatment of atmospheric convection. For hotter stars Balmer profiles are sensitive to both effective temperature and surface gravity. Provided we know the surface gravity of these stars from some other method (e.g. from eclipsing binary systems), we can use them to determine effective temperature. In previous work, we have found no significant systematic problems with using uvby photometry to determine atmospheric parameters of fundamental (and standard) stars. In fact, uvby was found to be very good for obtaining both Teff and log g. Using Halpha and Hbeta profiles, we have found that both the Canuto & Mazzitteli and standard Kurucz mixing-length theory without approximate overshooting are both in agreement to within the uncertainties of the fundamental stars. Overshooting models were always clearly discrepant. Some evidence was found for significant disagreement between all treatments of convection and fundamental values around 8000~9000K, but these results were for fundamental stars without fundamental surface gravities. We have used stars with fundamental values of both Teff and log g to explore this region in more detail.

Key concepts: Balmer series, Surface gravity, Stars, Physics, Astrophysics, Photometry (optics), Effective temperature, Stellar atmosphere

Related papers

Back to paper searchBrowse research topicsOriginal source
Using Balmer line profiles to investigate convection in A and F stars — Research Paper | ScholarLens