2006arXiv (Cornell University)Open access

The Distance to the Virgo Cluster from a Recalibrated Tully-Fisher Relation Based on HST Cepheids and a Demonstrated Teerikorpi Cluster Incompleteness Bias

Allan Sandage, G. Tammann

Open full text 2 citations

Abstract

The importance of the distance of the Virgo cluster in the ongoing debate on the value of the Hubble constant is reviewed. A new calibration of the Tully-Fisher 21-cm line width-absolute magnitude relation is made using Cepheid distances to 25 galaxies determined in various HST programs and reduced with the new Cepheid P-L relations that vary from galaxy-to galaxy. The calibration is applied to a complete sample of Virgo cluster spirals for the purpose of demonstrating the Teerikorpi cluster incompleteness bias. A diagnostic test is shown that should be useful in identifying the presence of bias in incompletely sampled data for distant clusters. The bias-free TF distance modulus for the Virgo cluster is m - M = 31.67 (D = 21.6 Mpc). A systematic correction of 0.07 mag is made because the cluster members are redder in B I on average than the calibrators at a given line width, giving a final adopted modulus for the Virgo cluster core of 31.60 + 0.09. If we assign a generous range of systematic error of ~ 0.3 mag, the distance D = 20.9 Mpc (m - M = 31.60) has a range from 24.0 Mpc to 18.2 Mpc (m - M between 31.9 and 31.3), and a Hubble constant of Ho = 56 between the limits of 49 and 65 when used with a cosmic expansion velocity of 1175 km s-1 determined by the method of distance ratios of remote clusters to Virgo. This range overlaps our preferred value of Ho = 62 from the HST Cepheid calibration of type Ia supernovae recently determined. The TF modulus of Virgo determined here cannot be reconciled with the recent high value of Ho = 72 from Freedman et al.

Open-access reader

About this research paper

What this paper is about

The importance of the distance of the Virgo cluster in the ongoing debate on the value of the Hubble constant is reviewed. A new calibration of the Tully-Fisher 21-cm line width-absolute magnitude relation is made using Cepheid distances to 25 galaxies determined in various HST programs and reduced with the new Cepheid P-L relations that vary from galaxy-to galaxy. The calibration is applied to a complete sample of Virgo cluster spirals for the purpose of demonstrating the Teerikorpi cluster incompleteness bias. A diagnostic test is shown that should be useful in identifying the presence of bias in incompletely sampled data for distant clusters. The bias-free TF distance modulus for the Virgo cluster is m - M = 31.67 (D = 21.6 Mpc). A systematic correction of 0.07 mag is made because the cluster members are redder in B I on average than the calibrators at a given line width, giving a final adopted modulus for the Virgo cluster core of 31.60 + 0.09. If we assign a generous range of systematic error of ~ 0.3 mag, the distance D = 20.9 Mpc (m - M = 31.60) has a range from 24.0 Mpc to 18.2 Mpc (m - M between 31.9 and 31.3), and a Hubble constant of Ho = 56 between the limits of 49 and 65 when used with a cosmic expansion velocity of 1175 km s-1 determined by the method of distance ratios of remote clusters to Virgo. This range overlaps our preferred value of Ho = 62 from the HST Cepheid calibration of type Ia supernovae recently determined. The TF modulus of Virgo determined here cannot be reconciled with the recent high value of Ho = 72 from Freedman et al.

Why it matters

OpenAlex reports 2 citations for this work. Citation counts describe recorded attention and do not establish research quality.

Key contribution

A contribution statement is not available in the OpenAlex record.

Method / approach

Method details are not available in the OpenAlex metadata.

Main findings

Findings are not separately available in the OpenAlex metadata.

Limitations

Limitations are not available in the OpenAlex metadata.

Applications

Application details are not available in the OpenAlex metadata.

Available abstract

The importance of the distance of the Virgo cluster in the ongoing debate on the value of the Hubble constant is reviewed. A new calibration of the Tully-Fisher 21-cm line width-absolute magnitude relation is made using Cepheid distances to 25 galaxies determined in various HST programs and reduced with the new Cepheid P-L relations that vary from galaxy-to galaxy. The calibration is applied to a complete sample of Virgo cluster spirals for the purpose of demonstrating the Teerikorpi cluster incompleteness bias. A diagnostic test is shown that should be useful in identifying the presence of bias in incompletely sampled data for distant clusters. The bias-free TF distance modulus for the Virgo cluster is m - M = 31.67 (D = 21.6 Mpc). A systematic correction of 0.07 mag is made because the cluster members are redder in B I on average than the calibrators at a given line width, giving a final adopted modulus for the Virgo cluster core of 31.60 + 0.09. If we assign a generous range of systematic error of ~ 0.3 mag, the distance D = 20.9 Mpc (m - M = 31.60) has a range from 24.0 Mpc to 18.2 Mpc (m - M between 31.9 and 31.3), and a Hubble constant of Ho = 56 between the limits of 49 and 65 when used with a cosmic expansion velocity of 1175 km s-1 determined by the method of distance ratios of remote clusters to Virgo. This range overlaps our preferred value of Ho = 62 from the HST Cepheid calibration of type Ia supernovae recently determined. The TF modulus of Virgo determined here cannot be reconciled with the recent high value of Ho = 72 from Freedman et al.

Key concepts: Cepheid variable, Virgo Cluster, Distance modulus, Physics, Astrophysics, Tully–Fisher relation, Hubble's law, Galaxy

Related papers

Back to paper searchBrowse research topicsOriginal source
The Distance to the Virgo Cluster from a Recalibrated Tully-Fisher Relation Based on HST Cepheids and a Demonstrated Teerikorpi Cluster Incompleteness Bias — Research Paper | ScholarLens