2014Penn Carey Law Legal Scholarship Repository (University of Pennsylvania)Open access

Doctrinal Categories, Legal Realism, and the Rule of Law

Hanoch Dagan

Open full text 6 citations

Abstract

describing Legal Realism as nominalism).23 See id. at 1371 (" [N]othing is True Law which is not Just . . .." ).24 See id. at 1381-83 (discussing the importance of the power to persuade).25 See id. at 1387 (discussing the legal system as a forum of societal change); see also Thomas W. Bechtler, American Legal Realism Revaluated (describing the law as a "means to ends"), in LAW IN SOCIAL CONTEXT: LIBER AMICORUM HONOURING PROFESSOR LON L. FULLER 3, 20-21 (Thomas W. Bechtler ed., 1977); Harry W. Jones, Law and Morality in the Perspective of Legal Realism, 61 COLUM.L. REV.799, 809 (1961) ("In realist perspective, choice, decision, and responsibility for decision are central elements for a philosophy of law.");Hessel E. Yntema, The Rational Basis of Legal Science, 31 COLUM.L. REV.925, 955 (1931) ("It is the faith of empirical legal science that ideals of justice not related to human needs are not true ideals . . ..").26 See HOLMES, The Path of the Law (insisting that "[n]o concrete proposition is self-evident, no matter how ready we may be to accept it . . .."), in COLLECTED LEGAL PAPERS, supra note 18, at 167, 181; LLEWELLYN, On the Good, the True, the Beautiful, in Law (explaining the role of common law as constantly reexamining its precedents to reach the good), in JURISPRUDENCE: REALISM IN THEORY AND IN PRACTICE, supra note 7, at 167, 211-12; Hessel E. Yntema, Jurisprudence on Parade, 39 MICH.L. REV.1154, 1169 (1941) (discussing justice as a theory focused on "the search for better law").

Open-access reader

About this research paper

What this paper is about

describing Legal Realism as nominalism).23 See id. at 1371 (" [N]othing is True Law which is not Just . . .." ).24 See id. at 1381-83 (discussing the importance of the power to persuade).25 See id. at 1387 (discussing the legal system as a forum of societal change); see also Thomas W. Bechtler, American Legal Realism Revaluated (describing the law as a "means to ends"), in LAW IN SOCIAL CONTEXT: LIBER AMICORUM HONOURING PROFESSOR LON L. FULLER 3, 20-21 (Thomas W. Bechtler ed., 1977); Harry W. Jones, Law and Morality in the Perspective of Legal Realism, 61 COLUM.L. REV.799, 809 (1961) ("In realist perspective, choice, decision, and responsibility for decision are central elements for a philosophy of law.");Hessel E. Yntema, The Rational Basis of Legal Science, 31 COLUM.L. REV.925, 955 (1931) ("It is the faith of empirical legal science that ideals of justice not related to human needs are not true ideals . . ..").26 See HOLMES, The Path of the Law (insisting that "[n]o concrete proposition is self-evident, no matter how ready we may be to accept it . . .."), in COLLECTED LEGAL PAPERS, supra note 18, at 167, 181; LLEWELLYN, On the Good, the True, the Beautiful, in Law (explaining the role of common law as constantly reexamining its precedents to reach the good), in JURISPRUDENCE: REALISM IN THEORY AND IN PRACTICE, supra note 7, at 167, 211-12; Hessel E. Yntema, Jurisprudence on Parade, 39 MICH.L. REV.1154, 1169 (1941) (discussing justice as a theory focused on "the search for better law").

Why it matters

OpenAlex reports 6 citations for this work. Citation counts describe recorded attention and do not establish research quality.

Key contribution

A contribution statement is not available in the OpenAlex record.

Method / approach

Method details are not available in the OpenAlex metadata.

Main findings

Findings are not separately available in the OpenAlex metadata.

Limitations

Limitations are not available in the OpenAlex metadata.

Applications

Application details are not available in the OpenAlex metadata.

Available abstract

describing Legal Realism as nominalism).23 See id. at 1371 (" [N]othing is True Law which is not Just . . .." ).24 See id. at 1381-83 (discussing the importance of the power to persuade).25 See id. at 1387 (discussing the legal system as a forum of societal change); see also Thomas W. Bechtler, American Legal Realism Revaluated (describing the law as a "means to ends"), in LAW IN SOCIAL CONTEXT: LIBER AMICORUM HONOURING PROFESSOR LON L. FULLER 3, 20-21 (Thomas W. Bechtler ed., 1977); Harry W. Jones, Law and Morality in the Perspective of Legal Realism, 61 COLUM.L. REV.799, 809 (1961) ("In realist perspective, choice, decision, and responsibility for decision are central elements for a philosophy of law.");Hessel E. Yntema, The Rational Basis of Legal Science, 31 COLUM.L. REV.925, 955 (1931) ("It is the faith of empirical legal science that ideals of justice not related to human needs are not true ideals . . ..").26 See HOLMES, The Path of the Law (insisting that "[n]o concrete proposition is self-evident, no matter how ready we may be to accept it . . .."), in COLLECTED LEGAL PAPERS, supra note 18, at 167, 181; LLEWELLYN, On the Good, the True, the Beautiful, in Law (explaining the role of common law as constantly reexamining its precedents to reach the good), in JURISPRUDENCE: REALISM IN THEORY AND IN PRACTICE, supra note 7, at 167, 211-12; Hessel E. Yntema, Jurisprudence on Parade, 39 MICH.L. REV.1154, 1169 (1941) (discussing justice as a theory focused on "the search for better law").

Key concepts: Legal realism, Doctrine, Law, Political science, Impossibility, Legal doctrine, Normative, Law and economics

Related papers

Back to paper searchBrowse research topicsOriginal source
Doctrinal Categories, Legal Realism, and the Rule of Law — Research Paper | ScholarLens