The Political Economy of Democratic Decentralization

No AccessDirections in Development - General1 Feb 2013The Political Economy of Democratic DecentralizationAuthors/Editors: James ManorJames Manorhttps://doi.org/10.1596/0-8213-4470-6SectionsAboutPDF (0.4 MB) ToolsAdd to favoritesDownload CitationsTrack Citations ShareFacebookTwitterLinked In Abstract:Nearly all countries worldwide are now experimenting with decentralization. Their motivation are diverse. Many countries are decentralizing because they believe this can help stimulate economic growth or reduce rural poverty, goals central government interventions have failed to achieve. Some countries see it as a way to strengthen civil society and deepen democracy. Some perceive it as a way to off-load expensive responsibilities onto lower level governments. Thus, decentralization is seen as a solution to many different kinds of problems. This report examines the origins and implications decentralization from a political economy perspective, with a focus on its promise and limitations. It explores why countries have often chosen not to decentralize, even when evidence suggests that doing so would be in the interests of the government. It seeks to explain why since the early 1980s many countries have undertaken some form of decentralization. This report also evaluates the evidence to understand where decentralization has considerable promise and where it does not. It identifies conditions needed for decentralization to succeed. It identifies the ways in which decentralization can promote rural development. And it names the goals which decentralization will probably not help achieve. Previous bookNext book FiguresReferencesRecommendedDetailsCited ByPublic Service Delivery in Turbulent Times Where Convergence Matters: Lessons from the Management of Covid-19 in KeralaIndian Journal of Public Administration, Vol.68, No.214 March 2022Different dimensions of decentralization and rural–urban poverty in PakistanPoverty & Public Policy, Vol.1229 May 2022Calling in "Sick": COVID-19, Opportunism, Pretext, and Subnational AutocratizationGlobal Studies Quarterly, Vol.2, No.39 April 2022Deproblematizing the Federal–Unitary Dichotomy: Insights from a Public Opinion Survey about Approaches to Designing a Political System in AfghanistanPublius: The Journal of Federalism, Vol.52, No.219 January 2022Decentralization Reforms in Developing Countries Designed to Champion the Interests of Central Politicians and not Grassroots DevelopmentJournal of Developing Societies, Vol.38, No.119 December 2021The Incoherence of Institutional Reform: Decentralization as a Structural Solution to Immediate Political NeedsStudies in Comparative International Development, Vol.57, No.19 November 2021Untangling territorial self-governance – new typology and dataRegional & Federal Studies, Vol.32, No.122 July 2020Decentralization, legitimacy, and democracy in post-Soviet Central AsiaJournal of Eurasian Studies, Vol.13, No.123 December 2021Regulating Midwives: Foreclosing Alternatives in the Policymaking Process in West Java, Indonesia11 January 2022Case Studies as an Immersive Approach for Unravelling Energy–Society Relations7 February 2022THE ESSENCE AND FEATURES OF MECHANISMS OF PUBLIC INVOLVEMENT IN THE MANAGEMENT OF GENERAL SECONDARY EDUCATION INSTITUTIONS IN UKRAINE IN THE CONTEXT OF DECENTRALIZATIONPublic administration and state security aspects, No.Vol.2/1 20221 January 2022Trends in Local Government Reforms: Case of Environmental Protection Authority10 June 2022Impacts of Decentralized Environmental Governance on Andean Bear Conservation in ColombiaEnvironmental Management, Vol.68, No.68 September 2021Federalism and urban primacy: political dimensions that influence the city–country divide in AustraliaInternational Journal of Urban Sciences, Vol.20169 November 2021Institutional Responses to the Management of Covid-19 Crisis: Lessons from the Bhilwara and the Ramganj Models of RajasthanIndian Journal of Public Administration, Vol.67, No.317 September 2021Decentralization and welfare: Evidence from a panel of countriesAnnals of Public and Cooperative Economics, Vol.3331 May 2021Literature Review3 November 2020Local Government/Governance System in Nigeria4 December 2020Decentralization's Effects on Education and Health: Evidence from EthiopiaPublius: The Journal of Federalism, Vol.51, No.129 June 2020The Noken System and the Challenge of Democratic Governance at the Periphery: An Analysis of Free and Fair Elections in Papua, Indonesia6 January 2021Decentralization and the Limits to Service Delivery: Evidence From Northern PakistanSAGE Open, Vol.11, No.122 March 2021Explaining voter turnout in local elections: a global comparative perspectiveContemporary Politics, Vol.27, No.113 October 2020Decentralization in Local Government Empowerment of Bangladesh21 May 2021Decentralisation and government trust in South Korea: Distinguishing local government trust from national government trustAsia & the Pacific Policy Studies, Vol.8, No.19 February 2021Better service delivery, more satisfied citizens? The mediating effects of local government management capacity in South KoreaAsia & the Pacific Policy Studies, Vol.8, No.19 February 2021Beyond decentralising the Nigerian Police: how Lagos state circumvented debates on police reformsJournal of Contemporary African Studies, Vol.6127 November 2020Interacting Capacities: The Indirect National Contribution to Subnational Service ProvisionPublic Administration Review, Vol.80, No.65 May 2020Types of decentralisation and governance: Evidence from across the worldJournal of Public Affairs, Vol.4815 October 2020Évaluation de la décentralisation et de la commercialisation dans le secteur de l'eau en milieu urbain au YémenRevue Internationale des Sciences Administratives, Vol.Vol. 86, No.3Direct and Simultaneous Regional Head Election in Indonesia with Government Efforts to Build a Balance of Political and Managerial ApproachesEast Asia, Vol.37, No.320 June 2020Citizen political knowledge and accountability: Survey evidence on devolution in KenyaGovernance, Vol.2126 August 2020Decentralization in Developing CountriesPersonal, Public and Political Impacts of a New District: Survey Data from Before and After the Creation of Ghana's Nabdam DistrictJournal of Asian and African Studies, Vol.510 June 2020Knowledge Claims and Struggles in Decentralized Large Carnivore Governance: Insights From Norway and SwedenFrontiers in Ecology and Evolution, Vol.85 June 2020Population and Politics, Vol.7914 May 2020Decentralization as a strategy of regime maintenance: The case of YemenPublic Administration and Development, Vol.40, No.26 April 2020Cities drifting apart: Heterogeneous outcomes of decentralizing public educationIZA Journal of Labor Economics, Vol.9, No.129 April 2020Decentralization Without DemocracyWorld Politics, Vol.72, No.223 March 2020Fiscal adjustments at the local level: evidence from ColombiaInternational Tax and Public Finance, Vol.4324 March 2020Decentralized forest governance and community representation outcomes: analysis of the modified taungya system in GhanaEnvironment, Development and Sustainability, Vol.22, No.228 August 2018Informality as Experimentation: Water Utilities' Strategies for Cost Recovery and their Consequences for Universal AccessThe Journal of Development Studies, Vol.56, No.220 February 2019Inclusive sustainable intensification of agriculture in West Bengal, India: policy and institutional approachesInternational Journal of Agricultural Sustainability, Vol.18, No.15 December 2019Experience With Managerial and Political Reform Measures at the Local Level in SlovakiaLinkage Switches in Local Elections: Evidence From the Workers' Party in BrazilComparative Political Studies, Vol.53, No.130 April 2019Governance for Urban Services: Towards Political and Social Inclusion in Cities3 March 2020Urban Governance, Democratic Decentralization, and Natural ResourcesFiscal Decentralization and Macroeconomic Management in Turkey9 June 2020Evaluation of Decentralization Programs3 November 2020Understanding and progressing health system decentralisation in MyanmarGlobal Security: Health, Science and Policy, Vol.5, No.118 June 2020Decentralization, Fiscal Independence, and Poverty in the PhilippinesPublic Budgeting & Finance, Vol.39, No.431 October 2019DEMOCRATIC DECENTRALIZATION AND DIGITALIZATION OF AUTHORITIES: THE EXPERIENCE OF THE EUMarket Infrastructure, No.381 December 2019Policy innovations for pro-poor climate support: social protection, small-scale infrastructure, and active citizenship under India's MGNREGAClimate and Development, Vol.230 October 2019Community-based planning, collective action and the challenges of confronting urban poverty in Southeast AsiaEnvironment and Urbanization, Vol.31, No.221 December 2018Isolated counties, administrative monitoring, and the misuse of public funds in ChinaGovernance, Vol.32, No.423 April 2019Decentralization and the environment: Assessing smallholder oil palm development in IndonesiaAmbio, Vol.48, No.104 January 2019Why rural Malian women want to be candidates for local office: changes in social and political life and the arrival of a gender quotaThe Journal of Modern African Studies, Vol.57, No.34 November 2019Is Divorce a Solution? Decentralization Effect on Economic Growth in Post-Civil Conflict CountriesPeace Economics, Peace Science and Public Policy, Vol.25, No.327 June 2019The impacts of decentralization on health system equity, efficiency and resilience: a realist synthesis of the evidenceHealth Policy and Planning, Vol.29(Suppl 2)5 August 2019Accounting and the enactment of power: municipal reform by Peter Leopold 1774–1775Accounting, Auditing & Accountability Journal, Vol.32, No.4Impacts of the new Decentralization Law 23/2014 to the implementation of Community Based Forest Management in Lampung Province, IndonesiaIOP Conference Series: Earth and Environmental Science, Vol.28521 May 2019Judicial Reasoning and Review in the Indonesian Supreme CourtAsian Journal of Law and Society, Vol.6, No.11 August 2018Clientelism in Decentralized StatesEmpowering people: Role for political social work in South AsiaInternational Social Work, Vol.62, No.213 February 2018Industrial development in decentralized conditions: experience of leading industrial countries and conclusions for UkraineEkonomìka ì prognozuvannâ, Vol.2018, No.415 February 2019Civil Service Reforms in the Islamic Republic of Pakistan: Progress So Far, Implementation Barriers and Challenges26 June 2018Introduction28 November 2018Decentralization and Capacity in Public Governance28 November 2018Panchayat Elections and Democratic Decentralisation in West Bengal27 February 2019Introduction: Health Systems, Decentralization, and Change3 April 2019Expenditure and Revenue Assignment: Principles6 September 2019Citizen Political Knowledge and Accountability: Panel Survey Evidence on Devolved Government in KenyaSSRN Electronic JournalData Management for Platform-Mediated Public Services: Challenges and Best PracticesSSRN Electronic JournalA general theory of power concentration: demographic influences on political organizationEuropean Political Science Review, Vol.10, No.41 June 2018Role of communities in fisheries management: "one would first need to imagine it"Maritime Studies, Vol.17, No.36 November 2018Decentralisation, clientelism and social protection programmes: a study of India's MGNREGAOxford Development Studies, Vol.46, No.42 May 2018Evaluation of decentralization and commercialization in the urban water sector of YemenInternational Review of Administrative Sciences, Vol.3315 September 2018Uneven Social Policies, Vol.9717 August 2018Rethinking the Political Economy of Decentralization: How Elections and Parties Shape the Provision of Local Public GoodsPublius: The Journal of Federalism, Vol.48, No.47 March 2018Relative Capture: Quasi-Experimental Evidence From the Chinese JudiciaryComparative Political Studies, Vol.51, No.825 August 2017Does Decentralization Improve Health System Performance and Outcomes in Low- and Middle-Income Countries? A Systematic Review of Evidence From Quantitative StudiesThe Milbank Quarterly, Vol.96, No.24 June 2018Who Honours the Rules of Federalism? Party System Nationalisation and Fiscal PerformancePolitical Studies, Vol.66, No.227 September 2017Fiscal decentralisation and good governance: convergence or divergence? The experience of commune councils in CambodiaAsia Pacific Journal of Public Administration, Vol.40, No.227 June 2018The Trap of Neo-patrimonialism: Social Accountability and Good Governance in CambodiaAsian Studies Review, Vol.42, No.117 January 2018The impact of central-local inter-governmental relations on cultural democracy's developmentAsian Education and Development Studies, Vol.7, No.1Local Governance1 February 2018Development Policy Review, Vol.36, No.3Introduction6 October 2018Reducing poverty through fiscal decentralization in Ghana and beyond: A reviewCogent Economics & Finance, Vol.6, No.15 June 2018Transformation from Below in Bangladesh: Decentralization, local governance, and systemic changeModern Asian Studies, Vol.51, No.612 January 2018The Impact of Power and Civic Engagement in the Decentralized Management of Natural Resources: The Case of TurkeyPublic Administration and Development, Vol.37, No.47 September 2017THE IMPACT OF FISCAL DECENTRALIZATION: A SURVEYJournal of Economic Surveys, Vol.31, No.47 November 2016Decentralized Governance and Devolution of Funds to the Panchayats in India: A Critical Analysis of Two StatesStudies in Indian Politics, Vol.5, No.120 April 2017Autonomy and Performance: Decentralization Reforms in Zhejiang Province, ChinaPublic Administration and Development, Vol.37, No.228 February 2017Legislative Framework of Governance and Tribal Development: Status of Forest Land Allotment for STs and TFDs under the Forest Rights ActContemporary Voice of Dalit, Vol.9, No.126 April 2017Politics, development and the instrumentalisation of (de)centralisation in Sierra LeoneReview of African Political Economy, Vol.44, No.15127 March 2017Conclusions: Intergovernmental Networks and Decentralisation in Europe1 December 2016Introduction and Overview21 September 2017Towards an Appropriate Public Local Government Unit for Sri Lanka21 September 2017The economic impact of the Friuli-Venezia Giulia autonomy: a synthetic control analysis of asymmetric Italian federalismThe Annals of Regional Science, Vol.58, No.111 July 2016Civil Society and Environmental Issues28 March 2017Building a Culture of Accountability in Service Delivery: Conclusions from the GDN Project on Varieties of Governance and Service Delivery15 December 2016Challenges in Institutionalizing Democratic Governance via Popularly Elected MayorDevolution and the New Politics of Development in KenyaAfrican Studies Review, Vol.59, No.319 December 2016Assessing the Merits of Decentralization: A Framework for Identifying the Causal Mechanisms Influencing Policy OutcomesPolitics & Policy, Vol.44, No.512 October 2016The promise and reality of decentralization: a critical appraisal of Sierra Leone's primary health care systemCritical African Studies, Vol.8, No.320 October 2016Decentralization of Health and Education in Developing Countries: A Quality-Adjusted Review of the Empirical LiteratureWorld Bank Research Observer, Vol.31, No.220 March 2017Village Government Corruption in-Post Decentralization: Democracy, Ethnic Diversity and Budget AuthorityJournal of Developing Economies, Vol.1, No.125 June 2016Demystifying Decentralization and Its Setback: Evidence From Thailand's Decentralization ReformInternational Journal of Public Administration, Vol.39, No.69 November 2015Regional tailor-made policy making in trade licensing administration-case of SlovakiaJournal of Public Affairs, Vol.5213 September 2016Decentralisation and Urban Governance: Trends and Lessons from Cities in Tanzania16 June 2016Theoretical Approaches to the System of Governance of Renewable Energy in China30 June 2016International Public Management Journal, Vol.19, No.4Cities Drifting Apart: Heterogeneous Outcomes of Decentralizing Public EducationSSRN Electronic JournalLooking Beyond Conventional Intergovernmental Fiscal Frameworks: Principles, Realities, and Neglected IssuesSSRN Electronic JournalRelative Capture: Quasi-Experimental Evidence from the Chinese JudiciarySSRN Electronic JournalInstitutional Change and Corruption of Public Leaders: A Social Capital Perspective on Indonesia12 September 2015The Impact of Decentralization on Educational Attainment in Indonesia12 September 2015Decentralizacja w polityce społecznej1 January 2016Experience with Managerial and Political Reform Measures at the Local Level in SlovakiaBlending Top-Down Federalism with Bottom-Up Engagement to Reduce Inequality in Ethiopia6 January 2016Multilevel Governance, Decentralization and Environmental Prioritization: How is it working in rural development policy in Scotland?Environmental Policy and Governance, Vol.25, No.622 June 2015Iron Houses in the Tropical Heat: Decentralization Reforms in Africa and their ConsequencesRegional & Federal Studies, Vol.25, No.526 November 2015Opposition parties and the decentralisation process in South Africa and ZambiaCommonwealth & Comparative Politics, Vol.53, No.41 October 2015Two steps forward one step back: decentralisation as a policy process in IndiaJournal of Social and Economic Development, Vol.17, No.211 November 2015Decentralization and Primary Education Service DeliveryAfrican and Asian Studies, Vol.14, No.3Expanding entrepreneurship opportunities through local governance: the case of BarbadosCommonwealth Journal of Local Governance, Vol.0, No.013 June 2015Devolution Plan 2000: dictatorship, democracy, and the politics of institutional change in PakistanDevelopment in Practice, Vol.25, No.424 April 2015Human Development in Pakistan and Bureaucratic PredicamentsInternational Journal of Public Administration, Vol.38, No.314 January 2015La décentralisation dans les pays en développement : une revue de la littératureRevue d'économie du développement, Vol.Vol. 22, No.4The Politics of Local Policy-Making in Urban Bangladesh: The Case of Rajshahi City CorporationAsian Journal of Political Science, Vol.23, No.119 August 2014Mexikos Föderalismus im Wandel13 November 2014A Natural Experiment in Political Decentralization: Local Institutions and Citizens' Political Engagement in UruguayLatin American Politics and Society, Vol.57, No.22 January 2018The Origins of Patronage Politics: State Building, Centrifugalism, and DecolonizationBritish Journal of Political Science, Vol.45, No.118 June 2013The Impact of Fiscal Decentralization: A SurveySSRN Electronic JournalPublic Participation in Local Councils in Malawi in the Absence of Local Elected Representatives-Political Eliticism or Pluralism?Journal of Asian and African Studies, Vol.49, No.629 November 2013Decentralization in Post-Apartheid South AfricaRegional & Federal Studies, Vol.24, No.522 December 2014What Reverses Decentralization? Failed Policy Implementation, Civic Supporters, or Central Bureaucrats' Expertise? The Case of Brazil's AIDS ProgramAdministration & Society, Vol.46, No.8Institutional complexity and unanticipated consequences: the failure of decentralization in South AfricaDemocratization, Vol.21, No.629 April 2013The role of a constituent process in state buildingDecentralisation and political participation: An empirical analysis in Western and Eastern EuropeInternational Political Science Review, Vol.35, No.4Decentralization and access to social services in ColombiaPublic Choice, Vol.160, No.1-212 March 2013Decentralization Reforms in Zambia 1991-2010Journal of Social Sciences, Vol.40, No.19 October 2017Vertical Decentralisation and Urban Service Delivery in South Africa: Does Politics Matter?Development Policy Review, Vol.32, No.s16 June 2014Centralized institutions and cascadesJournal of Comparative Economics, Vol.42, No.2China's provincial diplomacy to Africa: applications to health cooperationContemporary Politics, Vol.20, No.230 April 2014Participatory Forest Management in Ethiopia: Learning from Pilot ProjectsEnvironmental Management, Vol.53, No.42 February 2014Reinventing the Governance of Public Finances in Remote Indigenous AustraliaAustralian Journal of Public Administration, Vol.73, No.19 April 2014Effectiveness of Local Governance: Interactions Between Social Capital and Institutional StructuresAsian Social Work and Policy Review, Vol.8, No.13 February 2014A Historical Synopsis of Over-feminized Local Governance in Neoliberal TurkeyTurkish Studies, Vol.15, No.131 March Subnational in The Journal of Federalism, Vol.44, No.19 May to Fiscal in The Journal of Federalism, Vol.44, August Decentralization Improve of Evidence from Journal of Political Science, Vol.58, July the Rules of Federalism? Party System and Fiscal Electronic Accountability in Electronic Decentralization - A Survey of the Empirical Electronic for decentralization role can decentralisation in Lessons from and & Comparative Politics, Vol.51, the in Lessons on in South Journal of Agricultural Education and Vol.19, of capacity and of decentralized in Social and in Chinese Cities Journal of Public Administration, Vol.72, October 2013Decentralization and Poverty A Framework for the Review of Public Administration, Vol.18, Political in Local of IndiaJournal of South Asian Development, Vol.8, April 2013Decentralization in and Society, Vol.32, No.11 March institutions and Forest management by forest councils in and Society, Vol.32, No.11 March water management: The case of and of the Networks and in Management, No.11 January Social and or Local in and Decentralized in Electronic Forest Management in and South India: Policy and Vol.32, AND A AND INSTITUTIONS Administration and Development, Vol.32, October a How National Policies, and Local in a in and October Fiscal Policy It Evidence from the and the Economic Review, No.123 February of Decentralized Governance in India: Social or Institutional of Asian and African Studies, No.19 November by Party in American Politics and Society, No.22 January of Fiscal Decentralization in Developing in Water Governance in Africa: the Policy and Institutional of Conflict and the Political Economy of Decentralization: How Elections and Parties Shape the Provision of Local Public Electronic Decentralization: The Politics of Brazil's to of Politics in February and Political Evidence from South IndiaJournal of Development Studies, the of Natural Management for Local and in in & Natural Vol.24, with Citizens' of Health on Politics and Society, OF Administration and Development, Vol.31, May of The of the State and its Effects on Federalism in and in Comparative International Development, Vol.46, November Insights on and and Vol.32, June to Public and the Democratic State in India: Institutions in the in Comparative International Development, Vol.46, January in the local political on in Vol.18, January Decentralization of and for and Education Vol.36, February and Consequences of the New of in for a Electronic and Electronic de la les et of and governance: and Vol.37, November Governance and the of Local Political Lessons for Government Studies, Vol.36, Service and Empirical on Social Protection in Journal of Public Administration, decentralisation and Administration and Development, June for local governance in the Western Vol.17, October forest management in Africa: decentralization work for local Vol.37, September the of decentralisation on health of Health and Management, Vol.24, No.4The of and Learning from implementation in Malawi of International Development, Vol.22, April for the in Forest & Natural Vol.23, Framework for Institutional Analysis of Decentralization Reforms in Natural & Natural Vol.23, and the Development of Party in New Evidence From Political Studies, March is the Capacity of Local for in Evidence from of Development Studies, Vol.46, No.4The Impact of Policy in the Republic of Government Studies, Vol.36, Decentralization Process of Development Policy in Studies, Vol.18, decentralization in Africa: its to forest and Vol.37, No.119 May of Decentralization: A Case Indigenous in the Political Science Review, Vol.31, in Governance and A Democratic Analysis with to in in Vol.8, No.11 January that in and Development Review, Vol.32, Impact of Decentralisation on Local Development: The Case of December and of Electronic Decentralization: Local Economic Development in Electronic and Political Evidence from South Electronic of Decentralization: Environmental Impact and Water in & Policy, the Assessing the of Environmental Governance Approaches to in & Policy, in India: Towards or Journal of Local Governance, Vol.0, November of local government in PakistanDevelopment in Practice, Vol.19, with Governance in January and in Public Administration The Case of Journal of Public Administration, Vol.32, that is not new public management and